February 27, 2015

School Faces Immediate Backlash for Adding These Four Words to the Pledge of Allegiance

Don’t mess with the Pledge of Allegiance.

That’s a lesson several student leaders at a Maine high school are finding out the hard way right about now.

Inviting the student body to stand for the pledge as part of the morning announcements, three teen girls started adding four little words to their routine that have caused a BIG backlash among many members of the community:
Four small words. One big backlash.
A few teen girls at South Portland High School in Maine are facing harsh criticism for giving their fellow students the option to abstain from reciting the Pledge of Allegiance.
Senior Class President Lily SanGiovanni started adding the words "if you'd like to" when asking her peers to join her in promising their loyalty to the nation, according to local media.
SanGiovanni, Senior Class Vice President Morrigan Turner, and their friend Gaby Ferrell say they started to think seriously about the topic after some teachers made students feel uncomfortable for not conforming, the Bangor Daily News reported.
They discovered that state law requires schools to allow every student to have the opportunity to recite the Pledge of Allegiance but “may not require a student to recite the Pledge of Allegiance.”
"We are not doing this because we hate America or anything. We are really doing this because we understand there are people who choose to say the pledge and it means a lot to them and for others it doesn't," SanGiovanni told WCSH.
The young women want people to be free to think about what the pledge means to them and decide for themselves whether they want to participate. 
Not everyone agrees.
Critics reportedly derided the girls on social media and sent emails to the school questioning the phrase’s inclusion in the morning announcements.
"There were some people saying we should go to Syria or Russia or Afghanistan and that will change us. It’s really hard to hear that coming from your community," Turner told the local paper.
Principal Ryan Caron says that he asked SanGiovanni to stop saying, "if you'd like to," because of school procedure, not outside pressure.
“From the high school’s perspective, this is a procedure issue. I don’t have an issue with the girls,” he said in an interview with Yahoo News.


  1. Achtung ... papers please ..... !!!

  2. Could the attitude exposed here have anything to do with the way America is being run (into the ground) today?

  3. The law states that they are NOT REQUIRED to say the pledge, whats the BFD about?

  4. I think the idea of saying "if you're like to" weakens the suggestion too much. The school should be asking the students to pledge allegiance to the flag, and "if you're like to" shouldn't be included in the request. If a student chooses not to, even after being asked to, then of course nothing would happen to them, which is fair enough.

  5. Tov even pretend this country even remotely resembles the country is was even a scant twenty years ago is a sick joke.

    The phony baloney US of Everything Is Rigged, Illegal (or pending)

    And we have the private profit (listed on the stock market) prisons to prove it.
    Just for starters..

  6. Hah! "we" would just lip-sync it. ;-)